Request Demo

A Comparison Of 9 Best HTML5 Video Players For Online Video Streaming In 2024

Published On April 26th, 2024 14177Streaming Tech
Explore More About HLS Player

HTML5 video players significantly play an important role in the world of streaming architecture and contribute their share towards the enrichment of content distribution across platforms or devices.

Initially introduced to the market in 2014, HTML5 video players quickly gained widespread adoption due to their superior technologies compared to other options available in the market.

These online video players are highly compatible and flexible, easily assisting broadcasters, publishers, or content distributors in reaching a larger set of demographics with their compiled streams.

However, if you require more control over your video assets in terms of how they are displayed and how users interact with your content, then you might need a privately-owned custom video player.

Today, HTML5 video players aren’t limited to web usage; they tend to deliver high-quality broadcasts across major device platforms such as mobile, tablet, smart TV, etc.

With the rapid growth of the live streaming & OTT industry, a number of publishers and over-the-top service providers rely on advanced player technology, including the best HTML5 video players, to distribute their content across regions and engage and connect with their viewers quickly.

But before we delve into the details, let’s take a closer look at what an HTML5 video player does.

Best HTML5 Video Players:

HTML5 video players have become essential for web developers and content creators looking to deliver high-quality video content to users across various devices.

These video players are designed to support the HTML5 video element, offering compatibility, customization options, and features like adaptive streaming, cross-browser support, and more. 

Here are some of the best HTML5 video players available in the market:

  • VPlayed
  • THEOPlayer
  • Kaltura
  • JW Player
  • Flow Player
  • Brid.TV
  • VideoJS
  • Muvi
  • Dacast

These represent a selection of the best HTML5 video players, each with its own set of features and capabilities.

Let’s begin with a detailed overview of HTML5 players and their benefits, followed by an in-depth examination of each of the top HTML5 video players mentioned above.

What Is An HTML5 Video Player?

An HTML5 video player is a technology that allows you to play videos on websites without additional plugins or software. It enables viewers to watch videos directly on a website without opening a separate media player.

online video players

Built using HTML5, a programming language used to create and structure web content. HTML5 video player is essential for embedding videos directly into web pages. Most modern-day web browsers like Chrome, Safari, and Firefox fully support HTML5 video playback.

With an HTML5 video player, you gain control over video playback, volume adjustment, and the ability to add features like captions or subtitles. This technology provides a convenient way for content creators to present and share their videos online across various platforms and devices.

 
Want To Start a Streaming Business With Best HTML5 Video Player?

Top Benefits Of Streaming With An HTML5 Video Player

Discover the myriad advantages of utilizing HTML5 video players for seamless video streaming.

Enjoy heightened compatibility across devices, enhanced performance, and an overall improved user experience.

Explore how the cutting-edge technology of HTML5 video players can boost your content delivery, ensuring top-notch quality for your end audience.

1. All Device Compatibility

Most of the sophisticated browsers are supported by HTML5 video player that stream videos and are compatible with any device such as mobile screens, TV, etc.

This video player’s compatibility alone makes it very valuable. 

2. Fully-customizable Player

Nearly everything is configurable when using renowned over-the-top providers to cater to custom needs.

Receive immediate assistance from a group of platform developers who have pre-installed features and themes for your proprietary media players that can be customised.

3. Affordability

It should go without saying that open-source HTML5 video players are more expensive.

However, examining their free-to-use source code has a significant advantage that cannot be overlooked. Using an OTT solution with many integrations can be a long-term consideration. 

html5 media player

4. Resource Efficient

One of the best benefits of a HTML5 video player is its requirement is with minimum resources.

Unlike flash player, HTML5 does not require any additional plug-ins and thus it is simpler in terms of its functionalities which requires light-weight essentials. 

5. Easy Integrations

They enable developers or anyone who requires to share videos on any platform to easily integrate it.

Mostly, the video monetization platforms require the need to share content on different websites & a media player online lets you easily integrate videos with built-in video tags. 

Looking To Build Your Own VOD Platform?

Start and Grow Your Video Streaming Service With 1000+ Features & 9+ Revenue Models.

  • Highly Customizable
  • Life Time Ownership
  • Own 100% of Your Revenue
  • Full-Branding Freedom
Request Demo

How To Choose the Best HTML5 Video Player For Your Streaming Platform?

While there may not be a standard procedure for selecting a custom HTML5 video player, understanding the fundamental considerations is of utmost importance. 

In fact, most online video streaming platforms or video streaming servers come equipped with built-in players. However, to ensure optimal performance, look for the following aspects when choosing the right one for your business needs.

  1. Multiple Video Source Specifications

Browsers must be able to play your video source files in order to share your videos across various websites and video streaming platforms.

However, it’s unlikely that every browser will accept the same video codec or source file, so the HTML5 video player needs to handle a variety of video source requirements for seamless browser compatibility.

  1. Flexible Video Control

This guarantees that you can quickly display or conceal different video controls on different browsers which includes volume, download, play, pause, full screen mode, and others.

For  certain browsers, you can opt to conceal or disable features like “download” and “full screen,” amongst others.

  1. Tailor-made Accessories of Videos

By adjusting various video aspects, such as resizing a video and maintaining the aspect ratio and video size, makes content compatible with a variety of platforms.

Viewers will therefore be able to access high-quality videos on any platform.

  1. Added Functionalities

A solid HTML5 player not only fulfils the very minimum requirements but also offers additional features to provide your audience with a top-notch streaming experience.

Captions and subtitles, regulating playback speed, specifying playback start and end timestamps, autoplay, mute, loop, etc. are a few of the essential solutions.

What Are The Features Of An HTML5 Video Player?

An HTML5 video player boasts a number of features that render it indispensable for modern web experiences.

Primarily, it demands fewer resources, ensuring smooth playback without overburdening the system. Its seamless integration into websites and apps simplifies the overall user experience.

Furthermore, HTML5 brings advanced benefits and customization options, empowering developers to craft engaging media experiences.

With native video support across major browsers, HTML5 ensures cross-device compatibility and even provides offline storage capabilities.

The 7+ Best HTML5 Video Players For Streaming in 2024

When it comes to online video streaming, there are many HTML5 video players available.

However, some are considered to be the best HTML5 Players in the market because of their entensive feature list and offerings. VPlayed, THEOPlayer, Kaltura, JWPlayer, Flow Player, Brid.TV, and VideoJS are among the top HTML5 video players to be considered in 2024.

With that being said, let’s get right in and know more about each of them in the upcoming sections.

1. VPlayed

Robust Over-the-top streaming solution with 100% customization 

html5 video player online-

VPlayed is a one-stop streaming solution that provides unparalleled viewing experience using customized HTML5 video player. 

Ensure your viewers get a fastest video playback along with supported technologies like adaptive bitrate streaming across all devices.

Acquire the freedom to customize your streaming platform completely at VPlayed along with 150+ streaming features. 

Some Of VPlayed’s HTML5 Video Players Highlighted Features Are: 

  • Now you can stream videos in 4K added with multi-lingual support
  • Enjoy buffer-free content as network bandwidth is no more a worry 
  • Store & broadcast videos in MPEG DASH, MP4 formats for flexibility 
  • Videos can be delivered with future-oriented tech-stack like HLS 
  • Fastest playback with simultaneous ad runs in seekbar thumbnails 

Pros & Cons

  • Ensures platform protection with domain validation
  • Offers subtitle settings for varied purpose 
  • Doesn’t provide free trials before opting solutions 
request demo

2. THEOPlayer

Premium video broadcasting solution used by dozen of brands 

html5 media player

THEOplayer is well-known HTML5 video player used by dozens of brands and online video providers globally.

This player is one of the first ones to be introduced in the market with supports customization of video players to stream on smart TV apps.

They are mostly used for OTT streaming and by payTV service providers. THEOPlayer supports other viewing formats like HLS, MPEG-DASH, which ensures smooth playability.   

Some Of Its Best Video Player’s Highlighted Features Are:

  • Offers dozens of integrations across wide combinations of video ecosystem
  • Extensive SDK support with detailed documentation making it go-to solution 
  • Enterprise video player is for media giants, large businesses worldwide 
  • THEOPlayer is the first to introduce Apple’s low-latency HLS streaming 
  • Provides high-end customizability & reliant video delivery solution 

Pros & Cons

  • Offers various testing tools 
  • Provides Player API & SDK
  • Pricing factors aren’t favourable 

3. Kaltura

Unified video platform for online streaming business with html5 player

html video player

Kaltura is a renowned multi-platform which provides HLS streaming solution & specializes in live streaming and e-learning.

Kaltura’s video player for website comes with reliant fast cloud hosting solution, so publishers who tend to choose this platform suffices their need.

The solution is backedup with plenty of third-paty plugins added with an dynamic API, allowing easy integrations with other services. 

Highlighted Features Of Kaltura’s Custom Video Player Are: 

  • A ready-made elearning platform with virtual classroom 
  • Best choice with its HTML5 video players engagement 
  • Multiplatfom support with unified development API 
  • Resource loader supports powerful player metadata 
  • Flexible player platform integrates with major ad networks 

Pros & Cons

  • Supports varied third-party integrations
  • Inclusive of cloud video hosting 
  • Lacks revenue-generating options 

4. JWPlayer

Video streaming platform with reliant Html5 video player for streaming 

custom video player

The initial source code for the first YouTube video player included JW Player.

But over time, the player evolved to include HTML5 streaming, and today it is regarded as one of the most reliable  video players available.

JW Player, which has been available for more than 15 years, is one of the major players in the video industry.

Nowadays, it provides thousands of publishers worldwide with buffer-free HLS and MPEG-DASH streaming.

Some Of Its Highlighted Features Of Online Video Players Are: 

  • Versatile perks include extensive 360° video, VR support
  • Offers video CMS alongside its player for video hosting 
  • Capacitates with handy audience engagement systems
  • Extensive cross-platform opportunities in Android & iOS SDKs
  • Delivers player bidding with content matching systems

Pros & Cons

  • Most well-established HTML5 players in the industry 
  • Provides AVOD & SVOD monetization models 
  • Direct support is only available to premium users 
 
 
 
Tired of using JW Player?
See why JW Player is not suitable to manage your OTT platform and why you need a JW Player Alternative

5. Flow Player

Performance-first html5 video player for exclusive streams 

html5 video players

Another strong video player and online video platform counts the Flowplayer.

It is performance-driven and furnishes with various streaming solutions with video file formats like HLS, MP4, MPEG-DASH, etc.

The robust html5 video player offers a variety of expert streaming options with hosting & encoding capabilities. Professional streaming works well with Flowplayer because of its speed and small size.

Highlighted Features Of HTML5 Player Video Are: 

  • Highly customizable with third-party integrations
  • Provides built-in ad based monetization options
  • Enables broadcasters to stream with API access
  • Easy to use with high engagement rates concurrently 
  • Ad-scheduling feasibility added with refined analytics 

Pros & Cons

  • Low latency streaming 
  • Live streaming opportunities
  • There’s no availability of free plans 

6. Brid.TV

Stream lag-free with compatible html5 video player 

best video player

Brid.TV is a premium online video platform that provides advanced HTML5 player with ad-based monetization solutions for mid to large-scale organizations.

Brid.TV’s lightweight video player offers adaptive HLS streaming service for live & on-demand video platform.

The HTML5 video player from Brid.TV features a full-featured video CMS as well as real-time video analytics that are accessible to all users.

Highlighted Features Of HTML5 Media Player Includes:

  • Enterprise video hosting is Brid.TV’s significant feature 
  • Supports latest VAST & VPAID ad tags in setup process
  • In-header bidding technology for maximizing ad revenue 
  • Get the facility to whitelabel vod platform with customized solution 
  • Provides full API & mobile SDK support for any media streaming 

Pros & Cons

7. VideoJS

Highly customizable online video player with plugin support 

best html5 video players

Video JS is a free and open-source online html5 video player that provides features with basic playback options such as autoplay or pre-load.

Video JS team uses JavaScript for plugging cross-browser irregularities, to ensure that your content appears in the best possible way.

They also help in adding support for HTML5 tags for other technical essentialities to introduce features such as subtitles & full-screen displays. 

Highlighted Features Of HTML5 Player Include

  • Video playback with VideoJS can be enjoyed on mobile & desktop devices 
  • Facilitates advanced plugins that support social media platforms easily 
  • Track video analytics right from the player & is one of standout features 
  • Branding can be added in player controls with include chromecast support 
  • It is an open source media player compatible with multiple 3rd-party plugins  

Pros & Cons

  • Brilliant customization potential 
  • Backend contains optional support for Flash browsers 
  • Need to have basic idea about scripting so implementation becomes difficult 

8. Muvi

best html5 video player

Muvi is a white-label platform for creating a customized HTML5 video streaming service. It offers powerful features similar to VPlayed, albeit it operates on a SaaS-based model. 

What makes Muvi stand out as the best HTML5 video player platform? 

Firstly, it allows extensive customization options to resonate with the brand image and target audience. 

Secondly, Muvi provides vibrant revenue models. This includes subscriptions, pay-per-view, ads, coupons, promotions, etc. 

Moreover, Muvi seamlessly integrates with popular systems, simplifying workflow connections. 

With its user-friendly interface and powerful tools, Muvi is the top choice for businesses looking for a reliable HTML5 video player platform.

Features of Muvi’s HTML5 Video Player include:

  • Customize your video player’s appearance with Muvi’s HTML5 player.
  • Enjoy exceptional video streaming quality with 4K resolution HDR support. 
  • Create a stunning website with pre-built designs optimized for HTML5 playback.
  • Monetize your videos quickly with skippable and non-skippable ads (supports both CSAI and SSAI)
  • Upload and share music files effortlessly with Muvi’s audio file feature.
  • Engage and reward loyal viewers with Muvi’s loyalty program.
  • Simplify video streaming with Muvi’s user-friendly HTML5 player.

9. Dacast

html5 player

Dacast’s HTML5 video player is an excellent tool that makes watching videos online a seamless experience. It’s designed to work smoothly on any device using a computer, tablet, or smartphone.

Dacast’s player is versatile and supports a wide range of video formats. 

You can upload and play videos in different file types without any hassle. This means you can share your videos with others easily, regardless of their device.

Another great feature of Dacast’s HTML5 player is its playback quality. It ensures your videos are highly defined, providing viewers with crisp and clear visuals. 

Additionally, Dacast’s HTML5 player offers smooth and buffer-free playback. It utilizes advanced HLS streaming technology to optimize video delivery. 

What does it mean?

Viewers can enjoy uninterrupted playback without annoying pauses or loading times.

Furthermore, the player deploys powerful features like video analytics and real-time performance tracking. 

So, you can track important metrics such as viewer engagement and playback duration. And this information can help you gain insights into your audience’s preferences and improve your video content accordingly.

Dacast’s HTML5 Video Player Features:

  • Customize and brand your HTML5 video player to match your business
  • Use HLS support for seamless streaming across devices
  • Increase views by embedding the HTML5 player on your website, mobile apps, and Smart TVs
  • Use chapter markers to indicate different sections in your videos
  • Monetize your content with secure paywall features for both live and on-demand videos
  • Host audio content like music and podcasts alongside videos on your HTML5 player
  • Control access to your content based on regions or domains
  • Add captions and subtitles to your videos for improved accessibility
  • Get 24/7 customer support to optimize your streaming experience

Conclusion:

In the current outlook, HTML5 players stand out as one of the greatest boons for businesses aiming to enhance online video distribution. 

Offering extensive customization, engagement analysis, and monetization possibilities, these video players ensure dependable and seamless video transmission.

Nevertheless, selecting the right one becomes more challenging due to variations in features, capabilities, accessibility, and other aspects.

While it may seem inconspicuous, understanding that the HTML5 video player is a crucial component of your video hosting solution that significantly influences streaming quality, speed, compatibility, sharing, adaptability, and various other aspects.

When choosing a solution, it is quintessential to closely examine all of its characteristics and specifics.

While the aforementioned comparative study may aid in decision-making, it is crucial to remember that your company has specific objectives to meet. Therefore, a hosting platform with a reliable HTML5 player must consider these objectives pivotally.

If You Already Have An Idea To Start A Video Streaming Business With HTML5 Player, Schedule A Free Demo And We’ll Get You On The Road To Video Streaming Success
request demo

Frequently Asked Questions(FAQ):

1. What is an HTML5 video player?

An HTML5 video player is a browser-based media player that allows users to play video content without the need for third-party plugins like Flash or Silverlight. Video player uses the HTML5 video tag to display video content and can be customized with CSS and JavaScript.

2. How to choose the best HTML5 video player?

With so many choices of open-sourced and commercial HTML5 video players, it could be difficult to choose the one that suits your business needs. Keep in mind that each one offers a variety of features at different price ranges.
Here are some of the features that you can check before the selection process.
1. Affordability.
2. Device compatibility.
3. Software updates.
4. Features and add-ons.

3. How to ensure that HTML5 Video player is secure?

It is worth mentioning that HTML5 video players offer better protection than any other online media players that use Flash code, even though no web video player can be said to be totally immune to cybersecurity risks. Still, the majority of HTML5 players provide viewers with secure streaming. The good news is that open-sourced players are just as secure as those offered for commercial use.

4. What are the key features of an online video player?

A feature-rich online video player can improve the overall user experience and take up the revenue to a whole different level. Here is a list of the top 5 features that are a must-have for any online video player to facilitate video streaming.

1. Simple to navigate.
2. Fully HTML5 video player.
3. Content security.
4. Multiple Ad serving models.
5. Low latency.

5. What types of video formats does the HTML5 player support?

There are three video formats that work properly in modern browsers. Unfortunately, none of these work in all browsers, so a combination of at least two are required for meaningful HTML5 video support. HTML5 players have three playback options: MP4, WebM, and Ogg. Note that only 58% of browsers support WebM, and Safari doesn’t support Ogg. Aside from that, MP4 is disabled by default in Firefox 24.

6. Which HTML5 player is best for video streaming?

The default HTML5 video player may appear to be a straightforward option, but it only provides basic capabilities such as play/pause and the ability to define the dimensions of your video. However, you can take it a step further by using a customizable HTML5 video player solution, which will provide you with extra video player options such as branding, closed captioning, and adaptive bitrate streaming.

7. What are the benefits of using html5 video player?

HTML5 video players are gaining popularity due to their unique features and solutions. Here are the top 5 benefits of using an HTML5 video player. 

1. Fewer resources are required.
2. Simple to integrate and manage. 
3. Provides full browser support.
4. Styled to your preferences in minutes.
5. Simple to add applications, tools, and links.

8. What are some best html5 video player for streaming?

Here are some of the top HTML5 video players available in the market:
VPlayed
THEOPlayer
Kaltura
JW Player
Flow Player
Brid.TV
VideoJS
Muvi
Dacast

Vijay Amirtham

Blogger and OTT Expert in VPlayed. Interested in digging deep into OTT Platform & video streaming media business tools and Love to discuss and share views on the latest technologies tips, and tricks.

37 Comments

  1. Martin says:

    Thanks for the guidance for how to choose best html5 video players with the steps and tricks. Nice explanation on each video player providers with their own unique features

  2. Stuart says:

    I was hesitant to switch away from my current hls html5 video player for video streaming, but after reading this post, I’m definitely considering trying out some of these options. The features and customization options are really compelling.

  3. Bruce says:

    The tips on choosing the right HTML5 video player provider were especially useful. It can be overwhelming to have so many options, so having a clear process to follow is very helpful.

  4. Maurice says:

    Great list of best HTML5 video players for streaming! I’ve personally used VPlayed Player with my ott platform before and found it to be really user-friendly and versatile. Thanks for the recommendations!

  5. Brian says:

    The fact that some of these online video player providers or html5 player offer features like subtitles and closed captions is really important. So nice thing is that you have mentioned about what is html5 video player and its options.

  6. Alan says:

    I love that you included information about the html5 video player builders with theri individual features . It’s important to be able to tailor the player to your brand and specific needs. Thanks for sharing

  7. Timothy says:

    I’ve been using one of the Html5 video player providers on this list for a while now, and I can attest to their quality and customer service. It’s great to see them all listed in one place for easy comparison.

  8. Nigel says:

    This post is a great resource for anyone who is looking for a reliable best HTML5 player provider. I appreciate that you included information about the features and pricing of each provider.

  9. Simon says:

    As someone who is new to HTML5 players, this list was super helpful in finding the right one for my needs.

  10. Derek says:

    I appreciate that you took the time to review each best HTML5 player on this list. It really helps me understand the features of each option and make an informed decision.

  11. Bernard says:

    I really appreciate that if you include pricing information for each HTML5 video player. It will helps me narrow down my options based on my budget.

  12. Mervyn says:

    I’ve had some issues with video playback on my website lately, so I’m going to try out some of the HTML5 video players you recommended to see if that helps. Thanks for sharing!

  13. Henry says:

    Wow, I didn’t realize there were so many options when it comes to HTML5 players. This list is a great starting point for anyone trying to choose the right one for their project.

  14. Gerard says:

    This is a great resource for anyone looking to implement HTML5 video on their website. Thank you for putting together such a comprehensive list!

  15. Naomi says:

    Nice blog with pros and cons of each html5 player providers, and the best part is you have mentioned the features of html5 video players. Thanks for sharing

  16. Natalie says:

    Thanks for sharing various hls streaming players with their unique features. It will be good for who looking to build their own html5 video players.

  17. Paisley says:

    Nice article on various html5 video player providers. If you could able to mention the prices it will be helpful for choosing based on budget. Thanks for the helpful article!

  18. Naomi says:

    I came across this blog post while searching for a html5 video player that could handle large file sizes. This various HLS Players has exceeded my expectations in that regard. Now its easy to make my decision on looking online html5 players

  19. Hannah says:

    I appreciate the thorough review of various html5 players on this blog. The information provided was really helpful in making my decision to use it on my website. Thanks for the great recommendation!

  20. Aurora says:

    we were trying out a few different branded HTML5 video players for video streaming and this blog post helped me understand the key differences between hls player providers. The comparison was especially useful in seeing how they stack up against each other. Thanks for the informative post!

  21. Ellie says:

    New to web development and I found this blog post to be a great starting point for learning about top HTML5 video players. The explanations of the different features and capabilities were easy to understand and helped me choose the right hls video player for my needs. Thanks for the helpful article!

  22. Penelope says:

    I wasn’t sure which HTML5 video player would be the best fit for my website, but this blog post helped me narrow down my options. The features for each hls players were really informative and made it easier to make a decision. Thanks for the valuable information!

  23. Scarlett says:

    I’ve been looking for a video player that can handle multiple file formats and I found exactly what I needed in hls video player. The in-depth review of various html5 player providers on your blog was incredibly helpful in making my decision. Thanks for the great resource!

  24. Sofia says:

    I found this blog post to be extremely helpful in my search for the best HTML5 video player. The information provided was clear and concise, and the comparison of different players was really useful. Thank you for sharing your knowledge!

  25. Abigail says:

    I’ve been using html5 video player for a while now and it’s been a great experience. Nice information about html5 video players for video streaming and with top streaming providers.

  26. Stephen says:

    Thanks for the comprehensive list of HTML5 players. I’ll be sure to check out the html5 video player for my next video project, as it looks like it has some great functionality.

  27. Preston says:

    The HTML5 video player is a great option for those looking for a OTT and VOD streaming and easy to use player. I’ll definitely be testing it out on my website.

  28. Ashton says:

    The best video player list looks awesome and each player has some great analytics and monetization options. I’ll definitely be considering it for my professional video projects.

  29. Tanner says:

    The VPlayed html5 player’s flexibility and scalability make it a great option for enterprise-level video projects. Thanks for sharing this information!

  30. Jorge says:

    I’m impressed by the list of features included in the HTML5 video players. I’ll definitely be giving it a try for my next video project.

  31. Josiah says:

    I’ve been using the HTML5 player for my video on demand platform and I have to say, it’s been a great experience. The customization options are endless and the performance is top-notch.

  32. Eduardo says:

    I love the sleek and modern design of the HLS Player. It’s perfect for creating a professional and engaging video experience for my website visitors.

  33. Colton says:

    Great article! The HTML5 video player options you listed are some of the best in the market. I especially appreciate the user-friendly interface of the hls player.

  34. Rodney says:

    This is the post i am looking for to know about streaming video players and top providers. Actually i am looking for benefits of using html5 video player in clear picture. Now i got the exact answer

  35. Joel says:

    I really appreciate the inclusion of both free and paid options in this article. The HTML5 video players looks like it has some great features, I’ll definitely check it out.

  36. Kenneth says:

    Thanks for sharing this informative blog post. I’ve been looking for a reliable HTML5 video player and I think I’ve found one in the best online player list. Can’t wait to give it a try!

  37. Bruce Lopez says:

    Thank you for your positive feedback on the article! I’m glad you found the HTML5 video player options mentioned to be among the top choices available. Specifically, you highlighted the user-friendly interface of the HLS player, which is greatly appreciated.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *